Knocknagael allotment row dominates Highland Council debate
Register for free to read more of the latest local news. It's easy and will only take a moment.
Inverness councillor Alasdair Christie launched a strong bid to save the Knocknagael allotment land from development, but lost by two votes.
The Inner Moray Firth local development plan (IMFLDP) will guide planning decisions in the area for the next 20 years.
It’s already been through five council committees and an extensive public consultation.
Highland Council officers said the consultation attracted 1240 comments, with nearly three-quarters specifically relating to the local detail of the plan.
And it was the local detail that bogged down a debate at Highland Council's Inverness area committee.
Across two hours of deliberations, Inverness councillors grappled with boundary tweaks and proposed development sites.
But the biggest thorn in the council’s side was the fate of green space at Knocknagael in Inverness southside.
The draft development plan allocates the area for mixed-use development, including up to 200 homes.
Inverness deputy leader Chris Ballance moved the recommendations, albeit with a caveat to reduce the number of homes to less than 100. His motion also suggested that the council could reduce the size of the allotments in future, if there isn’t local demand for it.
Councillor Ballance said this allowed as much flexibility for development as possible – given the huge demand for social housing in the city.
Knocknagael Allotments Association is currently trying to secure the land through a community asset transfer.
Councillor Christie tabled an amendment to protect the area as a community and agricultural site.
“The proposal from Councillor Ballance basically takes away this green space in its entirety,” he said. “It’s going to put 99 houses on a site, joining two existing estates.
“This is about ambition in a community. We’ve got a strong proposal from a community group, driven by people who care passionately about their area and growing initiatives. These are community orchards, gardens and allotments.
“The right thing for this is to support the community’s wishes, not to ride roughshod over them. There are other areas we can look at for social housing… before we take the last blade of green grass.”
After considerable delay, the fate of Knocknagael allotment rested on the vote. Councillors voted 12-10 in favour of the housing plan.
But it’s not over yet for Knocknagael, which could still secure the land through the asset transfer process.
Other tweaks to the IMFLDP had more success.
Councillors agreed to delay developing housing land in Croy until issues with the roads infrastructure and green space at the primary school are resolved. They also voted to protect Beauly’s Fraser Street allotments from development.
An updated draft of the development plan will go to the council’s economy committee in February 2023, before being sent to ministers to consider.
If agreed, it will come into force in 2024.
